Ergo
Proxy received mostly positive reviews, with critics praising the
series for its intricate visuals, cyberpunk aesthetic and intellectual
themes; while criticizing the uneven narrative and its over reliance on
philosophical references. Newtype USA stated that they were "excited by
the premise of the show, which features complex drama surrounding the
strikingly beautiful crime investigator Re-L Mayer, Cosplay Costumes and an intricate
sci-fi setting, incorporating robots, living in human society and a
grotesque array of unique monsters." Newtype went on to praise the
"tremendous supporting cast and carefully woven plot." Newtype USA
featured the first Ergo Proxy DVD in their "DVD of the Month" describing
it as "show that rewards viewers with a deep, believable, and above all
thoughtful sci-fi story instead of simply bashing robots together."[25]
Katherine Luther of About.com praised it for its cyberpunk themes and
mix of 2D and 3D animation as well as its deep psychological storyline,
calling it creepy, intense and "edge-of-your-seat-delightful".
THEM
Anime Reviews praised the visuals and pacing of the plot while noting
that the greatest flaw in the series is that the designs can be
inconsistent at times.[27] Zac Bertschy of Anime News Network gave it an
overall score of B+ and criticized the characters, stating "It's an
unfortunate stain on an otherwise excellent series." Ergo Proxy Costumes However, he praised
the animation stating "The backgrounds in particular are breathtakingly
detailed and beautiful, which is a surprise given the bleak, dystopian
surroundings"Carlo Santos also from Anime News Network criticized
the middle, ending and anime stating, "Some of the middle episodes fall
back on experimental gimmicks and fail to advance the story, while the
finale becomes a towering mess as it desperately tries to resolve every
single plot point. Even the animation has embarrassing moments of
inconsistency." However, Santos continued to state "for trying so hard
to scale the heights of a difficult genre, Ergo Proxy still deserves
credit. It accomplishes more than most other anime series ever hope to,
flaws and all."
IGN contributor D.F. Smith reviewed the series
DVD box set in 2008 giving the series a 7.0 out of a possible score of
10. Smith overall found the visuals, music and voice acting of Ergo
Proxy to be exceptional, but stated that the overall story was too
complex and relied to heavily on philosophical references rather than a
strong narrative. In conclusion, D.F. Smith wrote "Ergo Proxy isn't
without its share of disappointments, but even so, it has a heck of a
lot going for it. What it lacks in the way of a truly gripping,
involving story, it makes up for in part with a powerful soundtrack,
some powerful visuals, and the occasional powerful insight. If those are
the sort of things you go to Japanese animation looking for, you might
not find this series disappointing at all."[30] Another IGN columnist
Ramsley Isler placed Ergo Proxy's opening as the 10th greatest anime
opening. Isler praised the opening's use of dark visuals juxtaposed with
the opening theme song's optimistic tone, comparing it to a Nine Inch
Nails or Lifehouse music video.
No comments:
Post a Comment